JMO,
The Beyonce person sounds like a kid who is a new member here, asking for advice and didn't want to alienate the board by supporting Bey, and showing that they don't really love their own hair yet.
This is a very old thread, like 2 years old. Best to get the advice for your own hair and keep it moving. Debates about celebrities have no value unless your hair type is like theirs, and by hair type I mean curl pattern, and how the hair strand responds to products, which is almost impossible to know, because most things that get to the public are not always true.